Search
this site by entering keywords in the box below followed by the
keyboard ENTER key.
|

|
Teaching about the
Holocaust
A Resource Guide for Educators
United States Holocaust Memorial Museum
Washington, D.C.
The material on this page is reproduced with permission from the
US Holocaust Memorial Museum.
The United States Holocaust Memorial Museum's Teaching about
the Holocaust includes a section of "Guidelines for
Teaching about the Holocaust." It includes the following
sections:
Why Teach Holocaust History?
Questions of Rationale
Methodological Considerations
Incorporating a Study of the Holocaust
into Existing Courses
These guidelines can help educators present Holocaust material
that is appropriate for their students and is historically accurate.
The
primary mission of the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum is to promote
education about the history of the Holocaust and its implications for
our lives today. This pamphlet is intended to assist educators who are
preparing to teach Holocaust studies and related subjects.
Why Teach
Holocaust History?
The history of the Holocaust
represents one of the most effective, and most extensively documented,
subjects for a pedagogical examination of basic moral issues. A structured
inquiry into Holocaust history yields critical lessons for an investigation
of human behavior. A study of the Holocaust also addresses one of the
central tenets of education in the United States which is to examine what
it means to be a responsible citizen. Through a study of the Holocaust,
students can come to realize that:
- democratic institutions
and values are not automatically sustained, but need to be appreciated,
nurtured, and protected;
- silence and indifference
to the suffering of others, or to the infringement of civil rights in
any society, can -- however, unintentionally -- serve to perpetuate
the problems; and
- the Holocaust was not an
accident in history -- it occurred because individuals, organizations,
and governments made choices which not only legalized discrimination,
but which allowed prejudice, hatred, and ultimately, mass murder to
occur.
[Top of Page]
Questions
of Rationale
Because the objective of teaching
any subject is to engage the intellectual curiosity of the student in
order to inspire critical thought and personal growth, it is helpful to
structure your lesson plan on the Holocaust by considering throughout,
questions of rationale. Before addressing what and how to teach, we would
recommend that you contemplate the following:
- Why should students learn
this history?
- What are the most significant
lessons students can learn about the Holocaust?
- Why is a particular reading,
image, document, or film an appropriate medium for conveying the lessons
about the Holocaust which you wish to teach?
Among the various rationales
offered by educators who have incorporated a study of the Holocaust into
their various courses and disciplines are these:
- The Holocaust was a watershed
event, not only in the 20th century, but in the entire history of humanity.
- Study of the Holocaust
assists students in developing understanding of the ramifications of
prejudice, racism, and stereotyping in any society. It helps students
develop an awareness of the value of pluralism, and encourages tolerance
of diversity in a pluralistic society.
- The Holocaust provides
a context for exploring the dangers of remaining silent, apathetic,
and indifferent in the face of others' oppression.
- Holocaust history demonstrates
how a modern nation can utilize its technological expertise and bureaucratic
infrastructure to implement destructive policies ranging from social
engineering to genocide.
- A study of the Holocaust
helps students think about the use and abuse of power, and the role
and responsibilities of individuals, organizations, and nations when
confronted with civil rights violations and/or policies of genocide.
- As students gain insight
into the many historical, social, religious, political, and economic
factors which cumulatively resulted in the Holocaust, they gain a perspective
on how history happens, and how a convergence of factors can contribute
to the disintegration of civilized values. Part of one's responsibility
as a citizen in a democracy is to learn to identify the danger signals,
and to know when to react.
When you, as an educator,
take the time to consider the rationale for your lesson on the Holocaust,
you will be more likely to select content that speaks to your students'
interests and which provides them with a clearer understanding of the
history. Most students demonstrate a high level of interest in studying
the Holocaust precisely because the subject raises questions of fairness,
justice, individual identity, peer pressure, conformity, indifference,
and obedience -- issues which adolescents confront in their daily lives.
Students are also struck by the magnitude of the Holocaust, and the fact
that so many people acting as collaborators, perpetrators, and bystanders
allowed this genocide to occur by failing to protest or resist.
[Top of Page]
Methodological
Considerations
- 1. Define what you mean
by "Holocaust".
- The Holocaust refers to
a specific event in 20th century history: The systematic, bureaucratic
annihilation of six million Jews by the Nazi regime and their collaborators
as a central act of state during World War II. In 1933 approximately
nine million Jews lived in the 21 countries of Europe that would be
occupied by Germany during the war. By 1945 two out of every three European
Jews had been killed. Although Jews were the primary victims, up to
one half million Gypsies and at least 250,000 mentally or physically
disabled persons were also victims of genocide. As Nazi tyranny spread
across Europe from 1933 to 1945, millions of other innocent people were
persecuted and murdered. More than three million Soviet prisoners of
war were killed because of their nationality. Poles, as well as other
Slavs, were targeted for slave labor, and as a result of the Nazi terror,
almost two million perished. Homosexuals and others deemed "anti-social"
were also persecuted and often murdered. In addition, thousands of political
and religious dissidents such as communists, socialists, trade unionists,
and Jehovah's Witnesses were persecuted for their beliefs and behavior
and many of these individuals died as a result of maltreatment.
- 2. Avoid comparisons
of pain.
- A study of the Holocaust
should always highlight the different policies carried out by the Nazi
regime towards various groups of people; however, these distinctions
should not be presented as a basis for comparison of suffering between
them. Avoid generalizations which suggest exclusivity, such as "the
victims of the Holocaust suffered the most cruelty ever faced by a people
in the history of humanity." One cannot presume that the horror
of an individual, family or community destroyed by the Nazis was any
greater than that experienced by victims of other genocides.
- 3. Avoid simple answers
to complex history.
- A study of the Holocaust
raises difficult questions about human behavior, and it often involves
complicated answers as to why events occurred. Be wary of oversimplifications.
Allow students to contemplate the various factors which contributed
to the Holocaust; do not attempt to reduce Holocaust history to one
or two catalysts in isolation from the other factors which came into
play. For example, the Holocaust was not simply the logical and inevitable
consequence of unbridled racism. Rather, racism, combined with centuries-old
bigotry, renewed by a nationalistic fervor which emerged in Europe in
the latter half of the 19th century, fueled by Germany's defeat in World
War I and its national humiliation following the Treaty of Versailles,
exacerbated by worldwide economic hard times, the ineffectiveness of
the Weimar Republic, and international indifference, and catalyzed by
the political charisma, militaristic inclusiveness, and manipulative
propaganda of Adolf Hitler's Nazi regime, contributed to the eventuality
of the Holocaust.
- 4. Just because it happened,
doesn't mean it was inevitable.
- Too often, students have
the simplistic impression that the Holocaust was inevitable. Just because
an historical event took place, and it was documented in textbooks and
on film, does not mean that it had to happen. This seemingly obvious
concept is often overlooked by students and teachers alike. The Holocaust
took place because individuals, groups, and nations made decisions to
act or not to act. By focusing on those decisions, we gain insight into
history and human nature, and we can better help our students to become
critical thinkers.
- 5. Strive for precision
of language.
- Any study of the Holocaust
touches upon nuances of human behavior. Because of the complexity of
the history, there is a temptation to overgeneralize and thus to distort
the facts (e.g., "all concentration camps were killing centers"
or "all Germans were collaborators"). Rather, teachers must
strive to help students distinguish between categories of behavior and
relevant historical references; to clarify the differences between prejudice
and discrimination, collaborators and bystanders, armed and spiritual
resistance, direct orders and assumed orders, concentration camps and
killing centers, and guilt and responsibility.
Words that describe human
behavior often have multiple meanings. Resistance, for example, usually
refers to a physical act of armed revolt. During the Holocaust, it also
meant partisan activism that ranged from smuggling messages, food, and
weapons to actual military engagement. But, resistance also embraced
willful disobedience: continuing to practice religious and cultural
traditions in defiance of the rules; creating fine art, music and poetry
inside ghettos and concentration camps. For many, simply maintaining
the will to remain alive in the face of abject brutality was the surest
act of spiritual resistance.
- 6. Make careful distinctions
about sources of information.
- Students need practice
in distinguishing between fact, opinion, and fiction; between primary
and secondary sources, and between types of evidence such as court testimonies,
oral histories, and other written documents. Hermeneutics -- the science
of interpretation -- should be called into play to help guide your students
in their analysis of sources. Students should be encouraged to consider
why a particular text was written, who the intended audience was, whether
there were any biases inherent in the information, any gaps in discussion,
whether gaps in certain passages were inadvertent or not, and how the
information has been used to interpret various events.
Because scholars often
base their research on different bodies of information, varying interpretations
of history can emerge. Consequently, all interpretations are subject
to analytical evaluation. Only by refining their own "hermeneutic
of suspicion" can students mature into readers who discern the
difference between legitimate scholars who present competing historical
interpretations, and those who distort or deny historical fact for personal
or political gain.
- 7. Try to avoid stereotypical
descriptions.
- Though all Jews were targeted
for destruction by the Nazis, the experiences of all Jews were not the
same. Simplistic views and stereotyping take place when groups of people
are viewed as monolithic in attitudes and actions. How ethnic groups
or social clusters are labeled and portrayed in school curricula has
a direct impact on how students perceive groups in their daily lives.
Remind your students that although members of a group may share common
experiences and beliefs, generalizations about them, without benefit
of modifying or qualifying terms (e.g., "sometimes," "usually,"
"in many cases but not all") tend to stereotype group behavior
and distort historical reality. Thus, all Germans cannot be characterized
as Nazis, nor should any nationality be reduced to a singular or one-dimensional
description.
- 8. Do not romanticize
history to engage students' interest.
- One of the great risks
of Holocaust education is the danger of fostering cynicism in our students
by exposing them to the worst of human nature. Regardless, accuracy
of fact must be a teacher's priority. People who risked their lives
to rescue victims of Nazi oppression provide useful and important role
models for students, yet an overemphasis on heroic tales in a unit on
the Holocaust results in an inaccurate and unbalanced account of the
history. It is important to bear in mind that "at best, less than
one-half of one percent of the total population [of non-Jews] under
Nazi occupation helped to rescue Jews." [Oliner and Oliner, 1991,
p. 363]
- 9. Contextualize the
history you are teaching.
- Events of the Holocaust,
and particularly how individuals and organizations behaved at that time,
must be placed in an historical context so that students can begin to
comprehend the circumstances that encouraged or discouraged these acts.
Frame your approach to specific events and acts of complicity or defiance
by considering when and where an act took place; the immediate consequences
to oneself and one's family of assisting victims; the impact of contemporaneous
events; the degree of control the Nazis had on a country or local population;
the cultural attitudes of particular native populations historically
toward different victim groups, and the availability, effectiveness,
and risk of potential hiding places.
Students should be reminded
that individuals and groups do not always fit neatly into the same categories
of behavior. The very same people did not always act consistently as
"bystanders," "collaborators," "perpetrators,"
or "rescuers." Individuals and groups often behaved differently
depending upon changing events and circumstances. The same person who
in 1933 might have stood by and remained uninvolved while witnessing
social discrimination of Jews, might later have joined up with the SA
and become a collaborator or have been moved to dissent vocally or act
in defense of Jewish friends and neighbors.
Encourage your students
not to categorize groups of people only on the basis of their experiences
during the Holocaust: contextualization is critical so that victims
are not perceived only as victims. Although Jews were the central victims
of the Nazi regime, they had a vibrant culture and long history in Europe
prior to the Nazi era. By exposing students to some of the cultural
contributions and achievements of two thousand years of European Jewish
life, you help students to balance their perception of Jews as victims
and to better appreciate the traumatic disruption in Jewish history
caused by the Holocaust.
Similarly, students may
know very little about Gypsies, except for the negative images and derogatory
descriptions promulgated by the Nazis. Students would benefit from a
broader viewpoint, learning something about Gypsy history and culture,
and understanding the diverse ways of life among different Gypsy groups.
- 10. Translate statistics
into people.
- In any study of the Holocaust,
the sheer number of victims challenges easy comprehension. Teachers
need to show that individual people are behind the statistics, comprised
of families of grandparents, parents, and children. First-person accounts
and memoir literature provide students with a way of making meaning
out of collective numbers. Although students should be careful about
overgeneralizing from first-person accounts such as those from survivors,
journalists, relief workers, bystanders, and liberators, personal accounts
can supplement a study of genocide by moving it "from a welter
of statistics, remote places and events, to one that is immersed in
the 'personal' and 'particular.'" [Totten, 1987, p. 63].
- 11. Be sensitive to
appropriate written and audio-visual content.
- One of the primary concerns
of educators is how to introduce students to the horrors of the Holocaust.
Graphic material should be used in a judicious manner and only to the
extent necessary to achieve the objective of the lesson. Teachers should
remind themselves that each student and each class is different, and
that what seems appropriate for one may not be for all.
Students are essentially
a "captive audience." When we assault them with images of
horror for which they are unprepared, we violate a basic trust: the
obligation of a teacher to provide a "safe" learning environment.
The assumption that all students will seek to understand human behavior
after being exposed to horrible images is fallacious. Some students
may be so appalled by images of brutality and mass murder that they
are discouraged from studying the subject further; others may become
fascinated in a more voyeuristic fashion, subordinating further critical
analysis of the history to the superficial titillation of looking at
images of starvation, disfigurement, and death. Many events and deeds
that occurred within the context of the Holocaust do not rely for their
depiction directly on the graphic horror of mass killings or other barbarisms.
It is recommended that images and texts that do not exploit either the
victims' memories or the students' emotional vulnerability form the
centerpiece of Holocaust curricula.
- 12. Strive for balance
in establishing whose perspective informs your study of the Holocaust.
- Often, too great an emphasis
is placed on the victims of Nazi aggression, rather than on the victimizers
who forced people to make impossible choices or simply left them with
no choice to make. Most students express empathy for victims of mass
murder. But, it is not uncommon for students to assume that the victims
may have done something to justify the actions against them, and thus
to place inappropriate blame on the victims themselves.
There is also a tendency
among students to glorify power, even when it is used to kill innocent
people. Many teachers indicate that their students are intrigued and
in some cases, intellectually seduced, by the symbols of power which
pervaded Nazi propaganda (e.g., the swastika, Nazi flags and regalia,
Nazi slogans, rituals, and music). Rather than highlight the trappings
of Nazi power, teachers should ask students to evaluate how such elements
are used by governments (including our own) to build, protect, and mobilize
a society. Students should be encouraged to contemplate as well how
such elements can be abused and manipulated by governments to implement
and legitimize acts of terror and even genocide.
In any review of the propaganda
used to promote Nazi ideology, Nazi stereotypes of targeted victim groups,
and the Hitler regime's justifications for persecution and murder, teachers
need to remind students that just because such policies and beliefs
are under discussion in class does not mean they are acceptable. It
would be a terrible irony if students arrived at such a conclusion.
Furthermore, any study of
the Holocaust should address both the victims and the perpetrators of
violence, and attempt to portray each as human beings, capable of moral
judgment and independent decision-making but challenged by circumstances
which made both self-defense and independent thought not merely difficult
but perilous and potentially lethal.
- 13. Select appropriate
learning activities.
- Just because students favor
a certain learning activity does not necessarily mean that it should
be used. For example, such activities as word scrambles, crossword puzzles,
and other gimmicky exercises tend not to encourage critical analysis,
but lead instead to low level types of thinking and, in the case of
Holocaust curricula, trivialize the importance of studying this history.
When the effects of a particular activity run counter to the rationale
for studying the history, then that activity should not be used.
Similarly, activities that
encourage students to construct models of killing camps should also
be reconsidered since any assignment along this line will almost inevitably
end up being simplistic, time-consuming, and tangential to the educational
objectives for studying the history of the Holocaust.
Thought-provoking learning
activities are preferred, but even here, there are pitfalls to avoid.
In studying complex human behavior, many teachers rely upon simulation
exercises meant to help students "experience" unfamiliar situations.
Even when teachers take great care to prepare a class for such an activity,
simulating experiences from the Holocaust remains pedagogically unsound.
The activity may engage students, but they often forget the purpose
of the lesson, and even worse, they are left with the impression at
the conclusion of the activity that they now know what it was like during
the Holocaust.
Holocaust survivors and
eyewitnesses are among the first to indicate the grave difficulty of
finding words to describe their experiences. Even more revealing, they
argue the virtual impossibility of trying to simulate accurately what
it was like to live on a daily basis with fear, hunger, disease, unfathomable
loss, and the unrelenting threat of abject brutality and death.
The problem with trying
to simulate situations from the Holocaust is that complex events and
actions are over-simplified, and students are left with a skewed view
of history. Since there are numerous primary source accounts, both written
and visual, as well as survivors and eyewitnesses who can describe actual
choices faced and made by individuals, groups, and nations during this
period, teachers should draw upon these resources and refrain from simulation
games that lead to a trivialization of the subject matter.
If they are not attempting
to recreate situations from the Holocaust, simulation activities can
be used effectively, especially when they have been designed to explore
varying aspects of human behavior such as fear, scapegoating, conflict
resolution, and difficult decision-making. Asking students in the course
of a discussion, or as part of a writing assignment, to consider various
perspectives on a particular event or historical experience is fundamentally
different from involving a class in a simulation game.
- 14. Reinforce the objectives
of your lesson plan.
- As in all teaching situations,
the opening and closing lessons are critically important. A strong opening
should serve to dispel misinformation students may have prior to studying
the Holocaust. It should set a reflective tone, move students from passive
to active learners, indicate to students that their ideas and opinions
matter, and establish that this history has multiple ramifications for
themselves as individuals and as members of society as a whole.
A strong closing should
emphasize synthesis by encouraging students to connect this history
to other world events as well as the world they live in today. Students
should be encouraged to reflect on what they have learned and to consider
what this study means to them personally and as citizens of a democracy.
Most importantly, your closing lesson should encourage further examination
of Holocaust history, literature, and art.
[Top of Page]
Incorporating
a Study of the Holocaust into Existing Courses
The Holocaust can be effectively
integrated into various existing courses within the school curriculum.
This section presents sample rationale statements and methodological approaches
for incorporating a study of the Holocaust in seven different courses.
Each course synopsis constitutes a mere fraction of the various rationales
and approaches currently used by educators. Often, the rationales and
methods listed under one course can be applied as well to other courses.
United States History
Although the history of the
United States is introduced at various grade levels throughout most school
curricula, all states require students to take a course in United States
history at the high school level. Including a study of the Holocaust into
U.S. History courses can encourage students to:
- examine the dilemmas that
arise when foreign policy goals are narrowly defined, as solely in terms
of the national interest, thus denying the validity of universal moral
and human priorities;
- understand what happens
when parliamentary democratic institutions fail;
- examine the responses of
governmental and non-governmental organizations in the United States
to the plight of Holocaust victims (e.g., the Evian Conference, the
debate over the Wagner-Rogers bill to assist refugee children, the ill-fated
voyage of the S.S. St. Louis, the Emergency Rescue Committee, the rallies
and efforts of Rabbi Stephen S. Wise, and the decision by the U.S. not
to bomb the railroad lines leading into Auschwitz);
- explore the role of American
and Allied soldiers in liberating victims from Nazi concentration camps
and killing centers, using, for example, first-person accounts of liberators
to ascertain their initial responses to, and subsequent reflections
about, what they witnessed; and
- examine the key role played
by the U.S. in bringing Nazi perpetrators to trial at Nuremberg and
in other war crimes trials.
Since most history and social
studies teachers in the United States rely upon standard textbooks, they
can incorporate the Holocaust into regular units of study such as the
Great Depression, World War II, and the Cold War. Questions which introduce
Holocaust studies into these subject areas include:
- The Great Depression:
- How did the U.S. respond
to the Depression? How were U.S. electorial politics influenced by the
Depression? What were the immediate consequences of the Depression on
the European economic and political system established by the Versailles
Treaty of 1919? What was the impact of the Depression upon the electoral
strength of the Nazi party in Germany? Was the Depression a contributing
factor to the Nazis' rise to power?
- World War II:
- What was the relationship
between the U.S. and Nazi Germany from 1933 to 1939? How did the actions
of Nazi Germany influence U.S. foreign policy? What was the response
of the U.S. Government and non-governmental organizations to the unfolding
events of the Holocaust? What was the role of the U.S. in the war crimes
trials?
- The Cold War:
- How did the rivalries between
the World War II allies influence American attitudes toward former Nazis?
What was the position of America's European allies toward members of
the former Nazi regime?
World History
Although various aspects of
world history are incorporated throughout school curricula, most students
are not required to take World History courses. It is in the context of
World History courses, however, that the Holocaust is generally taught.
Inclusion of the Holocaust in a World History course helps students to:
- examine events, deeds,
and ideas in European history that contributed to the Holocaust, such
as the history of antisemitism in Europe, 19th century race science,
the rise of German nationalism, the defeat of Germany in World War I,
and the failure of the Weimar Republic to govern successfully;
- reflect upon the idea that
civilization has been progressing [one possible exercise might be to
have students develop a definition of "civilization" in class,
and then have them compare and contrast Nazi claims for the "1000
Year Reich" with the actual policies they employed to realize that
vision; the dissonance raised in such a lesson helps students to see
that government policies can encompass evil, particularly when terror
and brute force crush dissent];
- explore how the various
policies of the Nazi regime were interrelated (e.g., the connections
between establishing a totalitarian government, carrying out racial
policies, and waging war); and
- reflect upon the moral
and ethical implications of the Nazi era as a watershed in world history
(e.g., the systematic planning and implementation of a government policy
to kill millions of people; the use of technological advances to carry
out mass slaughter; the role of Nazi collaborators, and the role of
bystanders around the world who chose not to intervene in the persecution
and murder of Jews and other victims).
Once again, since most teachers
of European history rely upon standard textbooks and a chronological approach,
teachers may wish to incorporate the Holocaust into the following, standardized
units of study in European History: the Aftermath of World War I; the
Rise of Dictators; the World at War, 1939-45, and the Consequences of
War. Questions which introduce Holocaust studies into these subject areas
include:
- The Aftermath of World
War I:
- What role did the Versailles
Treaty play in the restructuring of European and world politics? How
did the reconfiguration of Europe following World War I influence German
national politics in the period 1919-33?
- The Rise of the Dictators:
- What factors led to the
rise of totalitarian regimes in Europe in the period between the two
world wars? How was antisemitism used by the Nazis and other regimes
(Hungary, Romania, U.S.S.R.) to justify totalitarian measures?
- The World at War, 1939-45:
- Why has the Holocaust often
been called a "war within the war?" How did the Holocaust
affect Nazi military decisions? Why might it be "easier" to
commit genocidal acts during wartime than during a period of relative
peace?
- The Consequences of
War:
- What was the connection
between World War II and the formation of the State of Israel? Was a
new strain of international morality introduced with the convening of
the Nuremberg Tribunals? How did the Cold War impact the fate of former
Nazis?
World Cultures
A course on World Cultures
incorporates knowledge from both the humanities and the social sciences
into a study of cultural patterns and social institutions of various societies.
A study of the Holocaust in a World Cultures course helps students:
- examine conflicts arising
between majority and minority groups in a specific cultural sphere (Europe
between 1933-45);
- further their understanding
of how a government can use concepts such as culture, ethnicity, race,
diversity, and nationality as weapons to persecute, murder, and annihilate
people;
- analyze the extent to which
cultures are able to survive and maintain their traditions and institutions,
when faced with threats to their very existence (e.g., retaining religious
practices, recording eyewitness accounts, and hiding cultural symbols
and artifacts); and
- apply understandings gleaned
from an examination of the Holocaust to genocides which have occurred
in other cultural spheres.
Government
Government courses at the
high school level usually focus on understanding the U.S. political system,
comparative studies of various governments, and the international relationship
of nations. The Holocaust can be incorporated into a study of government
in order to demonstrate how the development of public policy can become
directed to genocidal ends when dissent and debate are silenced. Inclusion
of Holocaust studies in Government courses helps students:
- compare governmental systems
(e.g., by investigating how the Weimar Constitution in Germany prior
to the Nazi seizure of power was similar to, or different from, the
Constitution of the United States; by comparing the Nazi system of governance
with that of the United States);
- study the process of how
a state can degenerate from a (parliamentary) democracy into a totalitarian
state (e.g., by examining the processes by which the Nazis gained absolute
control of the German government and how the Nazi government then controlled
virtually all segments of German society);
- examine how the development
of public policy can lead to genocidal ends, especially when people
remain silent in face of discriminatory practices (e.g., the development
of Nazi racial and genocide policies towards Jews and other victim groups
beginning with the philosophical platform elaborated in Hitler's Mein
Kampf, continuing through the state-imposed Nuremberg Laws, and culminating
with governmental policies of murder and extermination after 1941);
- examine the role of Nazi
bureaucracy in implementing policies of murder and annihilation (e.g.,
the development and maintenance of a system to identify, isolate, deport,
enslave, and kill targeted people, and then redistribute their remaining
belongings);
- examine the role of various
individuals in the rise and fall of a totalitarian government (e.g.,
those who supported Nazi Germany, those who were passive, and those
who resisted both internally, such as partisans and others who carried
out revolts, and externally, such as the Allies; and
- recognize that among the
legacies of the Holocaust have been the creation of the United Nations
in 1945, and its ongoing efforts to develop and adopt numerous, significant
human rights bills (e.g., the U.N. Declaration of Human Rights and the
U.N. Convention on Genocide).
Contemporary World Problems
Many schools include a Contemporary
World Problems course at the senior high level which allows students to
conduct an in-depth study of a topic such as genocide. The focus is usually
on what constitutes genocide, and areas of investigation include various
preconditions, patterns, consequences, and methods of intervention and
prevention of genocide. A study of the Holocaust in Contemporary World
Problems curricula can help students to:
- comprehend the similarities
and differences between governmental policies during the Holocaust and
contemporary policies that create the potential for ethnocide or genocide
(e.g., comparing and contrasting the philosophy and/or policies of the
Nazi regime with that of the Khmer Rouge in Cambodia);
- compare and contrast the
world response of governments and non-governmental organizations to
the Holocaust with the responses of governments and non-governmental
organizations to mass killings today (e.g., comparing the decisions
made at the Evian Conference in 1938, to the U.S. response to the Cambodian
genocide between 1974-1979, or the response of non-governmental organizations
like the International Red Cross to the Nazi genocide of Jews during
the Holocaust with that of Amnesty International to political killings
in Argentina, Guatemala, Indonesia, and Cambodia in contemporary times;
and
- analyze the relationship
of the Holocaust and its legacy to the formation of the State of Israel.
Literature
Literature is read in English
classes across grade levels and is also used to enhance and strengthen
social studies and science courses. The literature curriculum is generally
organized thematically or around categories such as American Literature,
British Literature, European Literature, and World Literature. Literature,
is capable of providing thought-provoking perspectives on a myriad of
subjects and concerns which can engage students in ways that standard
textbooks and essays do not.
Holocaust literature encompasses
a variety of literary genres including novels, short stories, drama, poetry,
diaries, and memoirs. This broad spectrum gives teachers a wide range
of curriculum choices. Because Holocaust literature derives from a true-to-life
epic in human history, its stories reveal basic truths about human nature,
and provide adolescent readers with credible models of heroism and dignity.
At the same time, it compels them to confront the reality of the human
capacity for evil.
Because so many of the stories
intersect with issues in students' own lives, Holocaust literature can
inspire a commitment to reject indifference to human suffering, and can
instruct them about relevant social issues such as the effects of intolerance
and elitism. Studying literary responses to the Holocaust helps students:
- develop a deeper respect
for human decency by asking them to confront the moral depravity and
the extent of Nazi evil (e.g., the abject cruelty of the Nazi treatment
of victims even prior to the round-ups and deportations; the event of
Kristallnacht; the deportations in boxcars; the mass killings; and the
so-called medical experiments of Nazi doctors);
- recognize the deeds of
heroism demonstrated by teenagers and adults in ghettos and concentration
camps (e.g., the couriers who smuggled messages, goods, and weapons
in and out of the Warsaw Ghetto; the partisans who used arms to resist
the Nazis; the uprisings and revolts in various ghettos including Warsaw
and in killing centers such as Treblinka);
- explore the spiritual resistance
evidenced in literary responses which portray the irrepressible dignity
of people who transcended the evil of their murderers, as found, for
example, in the clandestine writing of diaries, poetry, and plays;
- recognize the different
roles which were assumed or thrust upon people during the Holocaust,
such as victim, oppressor, bystander, and rescuer;
- examine the moral choices,
or absence of choices, which were confronted by both young and old,
victim and perpetrator; and
- analyze the corruption
of language cultivated by the Nazis, particularly in the use of euphemisms
to mask their evil intent (e.g., their use of the terms "emigration"
for expulsion, "evacuation" for deportation, "deportation"
for transportation to concentration camps and killing centers, "police
actions" for round-ups that typically led to mass murder, and "Final
Solution" for the planned annihilation of every Jew in Europe).
Art and Art History
One of the goals for studying
art history is to enable students to understand the role of art in society.
The Holocaust can be incorporated into a study of art and art history
to illuminate how the Nazis used art for propagandistic purposes, and
how victims used artistic expression to communicate their protest, despair,
and/or hope. A study of art during the Holocaust helps students:
- analyze the motivations
for, and implications of, the Nazi's censorship activities in the fine
and literary arts, theater, and music (e.g., the banning of books and
certain styles of painting; the May 1933 book burnings);
- examine the values and
beliefs of the Nazis and how the regime perceived the world, by, for
example, examining Nazi symbols of power, Nazi propaganda posters, paintings,
and drawings deemed "acceptable" rather than "degenerate";
- study how people living
under Nazi control used art as a form of resistance (e.g., examining
the extent to which the victims created art; the dangers they faced
in doing so; the various forms of art that were created and the settings
in which they were created, and the diversity of themes and content
in this artistic expression);
- examine art created by
Holocaust victims and survivors and explore its capacity to document
diverse experiences including life prior to the Holocaust, life inside
the ghettos, the deportations, and the myriad of experiences in the
concentration camp system; and examine
interpretations of the Holocaust as expressed in contemporary art, art
exhibitions, and memorials.
[Top of Page]
Conclusion
A study of the Holocaust can
be effectively integrated into any number of subject areas. Sample curricula
and lesson plans, currently in use around the country, have been collected
by the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum and are available for reference
purposes. For further information on the range of materials available,
and how to acquire copies of these materials for your own use in developing
or enhancing study units on the Holocaust, please contact the Education
Department, United States Holocaust Memorial Museum, 100 Raoul Wallenberg
Place, SW, Washington, DC 20024; telephone: (202) 488-0400.
References
Oliner, Pearl M. and Samuel
P. Oliner. "Righteous People in the Holocaust." Genocide: A
Critical Bibliographic Review. Edited by Israel Charny. London and New
York: Mansell Publishing and Facts on File, respectively, 1991.
Totten, Samuel. "The
Personal Face of Genocide: Words of Witnesses in the Classroom."
Special Issue of the Social Science Record ("Genocide: Issues, Approaches,
Resources") 24, 2 (1987): 63-67.
|